Not the best review, but when you look at the site you'll notice that Kat is a tough critic and of the most recent reviews three stars is the highest rating.
Of course I'm thrilled that she liked my story, and I think she probably was a bit harsh on Craig's story due to the dialogue that she didn't like. I haven't read Scarecrow yet, so I cannot comment on it, but I have read Craig's work and he's a fantastic writer. I'm proud to share the pages with him. Can't win 'em all. Even considering the kind commentary about The Madness, she still only gave my novella 3/5 stars on its own, so there you have it.
I would still encourage anyone to check out the review HERE. It's not the best we've had, but I gladly take the good with the bad. You can't please everyone.
After reading the review, why don't you see for yourself. Purchase S and the M HERE.